Monday, February 28, 2011

This is the end II


JB v A.N. Other, January 2011

HIM: "Draw?" 

It wasn't an unreasonable offer from Black.  His flag was hanging and the position which we'd reached was, after all, drawn.

ME: "Let's play it out."

Usually I'd have agreed to split the point straight away, but this was the last round of the tournament and ours was the only game still to finish.  The final game of the final round going all the way to stalemate seemed rather appealing from an aesthetic point of view so I decided to play it all the way to the end.  As it happens, though, and somewhat to my embarrassment, the game did not in fact finish in a draw.  I hadn't even remotely been trying to win, and yet win I did.

I think I'll be playing this ending out next time, draw offer or not!  Anyhoo, this game, played just three days after the ending that I'd seen at Golders Green which had inspired the original post in this series, rather goes to show that I'm not the only one who can manage to come up short when only rather basic endgame technique is required.




Desperately in need of some stranger's hand


Was our man (rated in the 170s ECF - that's 2000+ elo equivalent) unlucky?  Yes, absolutely.  Rushing to beat the fall of his flag, and at the end of a long night, he simply put his king on the wrong square when faced with a choice of two.  In the heat of battle it could have happened to anybody.

On the other hand, as Jesus de la Villa writes in the introduction to his book,


... if you intend to reach a certain rating, I will not say that a good command of the endgame is essential ...

Nevertheless,

...if you neglect this part of the game, many half points, or even full points, will now and then elude you.

pdf sample from 100 Endgames You Must Know


Or, to put it another way, it's not enough to know that the position at the head of today's blog is drawn.  We must also know how to draw it and be able to put that knowledge into practice when the time comes.  Perhaps, then, it would be more accurate to say that when we end up losing positions such as these it is partly due to bad luck and partly what we call 'playing chess'.

So we can conclude that these basic, easily studied, positions deserve our respect and attention?  OK, but which are the fundamental positions that we need to know if we are to avoid coming a cropper?  I guess Jesus de la Villa gives one answer to that one, but since I haven't read his book I've had to make up my own - much shorter - list.

I wonder who amongst our esteemed readership,
(a) knows the theoretical evaluation of each position;
(b) knows how to proceed;
(c) has had such a position before in a game (blitz/rapidplay/otb/correspondence) before? 
Personally, I can say yes to (a) for most of the 19 but, the king and pawn positions aside, I do considerably less well with (b). I guess, then, I've got a bit of work to do or I'm going to end up rather embarrassed should I start get to say 'yes' a few more times for (c).




1


2


3

White to play


4

Black to play


5

White to play


6

Black to play


7


8

White to play


9

White to play


10


11


12


13


14

White to play


15

Black to play


16

White to play


17


18

White to play


19

White to play





Positions taken from/inspired by:-
Bruce Pandolfini: Pandolfini's Endgame Course
John Emms: The Survival Guide to Rook Endings
Ian Mullen et al: Master Chess: A Course in 21 Lessons



Previously:-
This is the end







Saturday, February 26, 2011

Every Picture Tells A Story: Thomas Leeming, Artist and Networker, Part 1.

Number 6 in a series of collaborative posts. This one by Richard Tillett with comment by Martin Smith.

In our five previous posts we have told the story – which is still unfolding – of our research into an early 19th century painting, The Gentlemen of the Hereford Chess Society. This is the picture...


…and this is the man who painted it, Thomas Leeming.


We have come a long way since our researches began in December 2009, and it is time to take stock. In today’s post we reflect on what we’ve established about the artist from online resources and from various libraries and archives in Hereford and London. There’s too much for one blog, so Part 2 will be on 19 March.

Not a lot was known about Thomas Leeming until Martin and I got on the case, even the dates of his birth and death were a mystery. We think (but haven’t yet established) that he was born in Lancashire around 1788. In spite of much labour in the online IGI (International Genealogical Index) and elsewhere, we haven’t yet identified the family he came from, though we think we’ve narrowed the field to three candidates. We’re determined to nail him down, even if the Institute of Thomas Leeming Studies has to make another field trip, which this time will be to Salford where the Lancashire parish records are held.

There’s another piece of crucial information about his early life that is still missing. How did he learn to paint? Most, though not all, professional artists at that time had some sort of formal tuition. We’re working on that one too…

By the time he was 20 young Thomas had left Lancashire and headed south, though if he was hoping to find fame and fortune both were sadly to elude him. The earliest record we have of him as an artist is 1809, when he signed and dated this sketchily-executed miniature.


One of Leeming’s early efforts: a miniature of Lieutenant Bateson
painted when the artist was around 21.
He seems initially to have domiciled himself in Oxford, though we have not found any evidence that he was a student there. We know he painted a portrait of the eminent Oxford surgeon and publisher John Grosvenor, which he exhibited at the Royal Academy (RA) summer exhibition of 1812. A mezzotint print by Charles Turner, probably based on this picture, was published in the same year. The print, which you can see here, identifies Leeming not only as the painter of the original portrait but also as co-publisher, suggesting that he may have helped finance the print’s production. Thomas clearly had ambitions.

By 1811 Leeming also had a base in London, at 10 Park Lane. This soon became his main residence and in 1814 he moved a few hundred yards to 79 Park Street, where he remained for the rest of his life. Then as now, Mayfair was a desirable part of town, if not quite as smart as it is today, so he must have had some money to pay the rent while he struggled to establish himself as a painter. Richard Horwood’s splendid 1790s map of London, which even gives house numbers, shows that 79 Park Street was on the west side of the street near the junction with Upper Brook Street. The house no longer stands, probably demolished in the last quarter of the 19th century during the redevelopment of Mayfair by the Grosvenor Estate.



Detail from Richard Horwood's map of Georgian London,
showing Park Street running north-south on the right, parallel with Park Lane on the left.
Carriages were manufactured and sold at the oddly-named Rhedarium.
Most years between 1811 and 1822 Leeming exhibited paintings at the RA – 23 in total. Of these, only one is known by us to have survived and that is the ‘Greenlees’ version of the Gents. Most would have been portrait miniatures, since that was his main business. The RA exhibitions were important marketing opportunities for ambitious painters and the miniaturists had their own area around the fireplace in the main exhibition area where they displayed their wares.


Detail from The Exhibition of the Royal Academy, 1787,
by Pietro Antonio Martini after a drawing by Johann Heinrich Ramberg,
showing the miniatures on display.
We recently discovered that Leeming was also a copyist of some repute and it is likely that some of the pictures he exhibited at the RA were copies, such as his portrait of the Duke of Sussex, one of George III’s sons, which he may have hoped would catch the eye of upmarket patrons.

We also now know that Leeming was an accomplished networker – he was “warmly esteemed and respected by an extensive circle of friends in different parts of the Kingdom” according to a contemporary source. At some point, probably around 1813/14, he started to connect with the great and the good of Hereford. A promising seam of work quickly opened up, perhaps because there was less competition there than in London, and other provincial cities of the time such as Norwich with its famous school of artists. We know that Leeming painted portraits of the local bigwigs Lord Harley and Colonel Matthews. His Herefordshire sitters also included a Miss Holder, who was probably related to Matthews, the Reverend Thomas Russell, who was a canon at Hereford Cathedral, and a lady of Viscount Hereford’s family.


An accomplished miniature painted by Leeming in 1819
of the Hon Juliana Marianna Stratford Devereux,
daughter of the 13th Viscount Hereford.
And then there are the Gents themselves, six young men from the higher echelons of Hereford society at the start of their professional lives. Three of them rose to local prominence – Edwin Goode Wright, who was editor and publisher of the Hereford Journal for 40 years, and Francis Lewis Bodenham, who was to serve twice as mayor of Hereford. John Allen Junior was a bibliophile and antiquarian whose short but extraordinary life included a painful and very public encounter with the laws of libel, which we will return to in a future blog.

But what of the odd-man-out, the Gent in the red coat who appears only in the ‘Greenlees’ version, and is not a Hereford man at all? Sotheby’s identified him as ‘Mr Buckson’ from the inscription on the painting when they sold it in 1991, but we’re confident that he is actually James Buckton, a London lawyer and close friend of the artist.

If you’re wondering what a London lawyer was up to hanging out at a Hereford chess club, so did we. What’s more, we found the answer… the missing Links you might say. We’ve documented a tale of love, marriage, joy and tragedy, and at the centre of the drama are two young Hereford sisters, Mary and Eliza Link. But you’ll have to wait for that too.

Totally gratuitous footnote:

The Royal Academy exhibitions were major social occasions which became notorious for what one writer (David Solkin) has described as their ‘sexualised atmosphere’. According to Vicenç Furió in an article in Locvs Amcenvs:

“A number of sexual scandals took place within the context of the exhibitions…such as the one concerning the steep staircase that led to the top floor where the Great Room was located. Falls on these stairs were commonplace, and it seems that views of backsides and other parts of the female anatomy that these falls provided became one of the main lures to visit the exhibition.”
Acknowledgments:
Hereford history: thanks to David Whitehead for briefing us on the Gents in the picture and suggesting identities for some of Leeming’s RA sitters.
Portrait of Lieutenant Bateson: Bonhams, London, Portrait Miniatures & Silhouettes, 2 Sep 2008, lot 65.
The Martini print and the footnote on RA exhibitions: Seeing Art History: Pietro Antonio Martini’s Engravings on the Exhibitions of Paris and London in 1787 by Vicenç Furió, Locvs Amoenvs 7, 2004. Image sourced from here.
Portrait of the Hon Juliana Marianna Stratford Devereux: Artnet.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Once was enough II : Portuguese Gambit



1.e4 d5 2.exd5 Nf6 3.d4 Bg4

Although this series is not going to follow a chronological order, this, the second part, does in fact follow on directly from the first. Having lost the first leg of a two-game match with the Latvian Gambit, I surprisingly won the second and thereby found myself in a rapidplay play-off, again over two legs.

Although the two normal-rate games had taken place six weeks apart, the first of the rapidplay games was arranged for just three days after my second-leg win. The only other chess I played during those six weeks had been a quickplay tournament: I met 1.e4 four times, each time replying with 1...e5 and scoring three losses and a draw. This may have been influential in persuading me to play something different against Adam (though, as we shall see, it may not) and I chose to play the recently-trendy Portuguese Gambit.

WHERE I FOUND IT: I believe I'd seen an article or two about it, which had persuaded me to get hold of a then-new book by Selby Anderson, which made use of a lot of computer analysis (this was not standard practice back in those days) to make a case for it.

In the Portuguese, reckons the back cover,
Black offers a pawn for rapid development and the chance to exploit weak squares in the enemy camp.
Go on...
The resulting play is sharp and trappy, with plenty of "coffeehouse" flavour for those wishing to mix it up with Black.
I don't suppose those are a couple of John Nunn's "secret code words"? The book thinks not:
No mere surprise weapon, however, the Portuguese has been tested in the fire of world class tournament chess. Proof of the line's vitality is it's (sic) adoption by aggressive Grandmasters such as Spraggett, Hodgson, Shirov and Hebden.
I think, now, I might query the term "proof". I might also be inclined to interpret the claim
the high percentage of original analysis found here stands in stark contrast to the typical opening monograph.
as meaning "has lots of untested analysis and very few actual games". But we are all wiser with age, or think we are.

WHY I PLAYED IT: I could claim that I prepared it specially as a one-off opening against a strong player, though given that I'd just suffered a heavy defeat against the same player using much that strategy, it would still have been a strange way to proceed. But in fact, looking back, I'd actually employed the not-dissimilar Icelandic Gambit, 1.e4 d5 2.exd5 Nf6 3.c4 e6!?


twice in the previous fifteen months. As I've never played - nor, as far as I recall, intended to play - 3.d4 Nxd5, I'm pretty sure that against 3.d4 I must have been prepared, for quite some time, to punt a Portuguese. Although 3..Qxd5 is also possible: but if you're going to do that, why not take with the queen on move two?

I did, in fact, play 2...Qxd5 (and 3.Nc3 Qa5) for a while, having bought and liked John Emms' first book on the subject, abysmal production aside. I never entirely believed it though, especially as Anand, who played it against Kasparov to prompt my interest in the first place, absolutely pasted Lautier in a celebrated game just when I was taking it up.

I wrote in the last column:
So, with the logic that was informing my choices at that time, I replaced an intended line that was little-known and a little dubious with one that was even less well-known and even more questionable.
This was exactly the same syndrome. Of course it's easy at a distance to see that this is silly, but harder to see how to avoid it: moreover, if the opening looked potentially busted, one might as well play lesser-known and more complicated lines than go down the main line and hope they don't know Anand-Lautier.

Besides, as I was also still playing 1...e5, I believe the idea was to have more than one line available to me, so that I could vary, depending on the opponent. This is not at all a silly idea, but there are some large questions regarding implementation.

  • Do we really have multiple lines available to us, or are we just hiding the fact that we don't, as yet, have even one we can rely on? (I didn't.)
  • Is there not a tendency for this to get out of hand, so that you end up having several different lines for several different situations, and knowing none of them? (There is: a few years later I found myself trying to keep up with the French, the Sicilian and the open games.)
  • Is there a difference between having a combative line available, and reading up on a wild line requiring you to learn lots of tactical lines that you'll never in fact learn? (There is: and you're all the less likely to learn them if you only play it once.)

The books always talk about how your opponent is unlikely to know the theory: they talk less about how you probably won't, either.

WHY I STOPPED PLAYING IT: Not, especially, because of the result of the game: in fact Black, despite playing, inadvertently, down lines (6...a6 and then 8...Nb6?!) that Anderson dislikes, got splendid compensation for his pawns. (11.Qc4 would have been stronger, as would 12.Ne2, but that's the gamble - sacrifice for some compensation and see if their mistakes can turn it into lots.) Had I not blundered a knight away at move 19, I might easily have gone on to win. But I lost, and the second game was drawn.

I'm not even sure I gave it up straight away: the next time I met 1.e4 I played 1...d5 2.exd5 Nf6, but the opponent played 3.Nc3. After that, I never got as close to playing it again. At the end of the day you can't, really, play dicky lines which require you to learn lots of theory, in pursuit of an opening which you know is probably unsound, and which you will, anyway, never play enough to fix the theory in your memory.

Not unless you really, really like it. I didn't like it nearly enough: I was playing it because I was desperate. And if you're desperate, it's perhaps best to pick a proper opening, and see what happens.

CHANCES OF MY PLAYING IT AGAIN: None. I still like 1...d5: I can imagine myself being tempted to try it again, in its 2...Qxd5 and 3...Qa5 form, though it's probably a temptation better resisted. But the Portuguese Gambit is a one-off opening. And I've already tried it once.


[Once was enough I]

[Once was enough II]

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Sing a Song of Chess II

Chess!

Chess. The only game I'll ever love.
Kings and queens are what I'm singing of.

When I use Staunton pieces
My FIDE rating increases.









Previously:-
The Chess Machine

Monday, February 21, 2011

This is the end


White to play

When I was a student – when I was a student the first time that is – I was friends with a guy called Mikey. I haven’t seen him for more than twenty years now, but one thing I’m pretty sure about is that he didn’t turn into a club chesser. Purely on the law of averages, I suppose, you could guess that most people that you meet won’t take up chess as a hobby. I know that Mikey hasn’t though, and I know because of how he used the jukebox in the Union bar.

Yes, most of my evenings at Southampton University were spent in the students’ bar in the company of my undergraduate chums. We spent our time drinking watered-down beer, talking shite, playing the quiz machine and feeding the jukebox with ten pence pieces. While most of us would vary our musical choices night by night Mikey always, literally always, picked The Doors’ This is the End. It was, he said, the longest song in the jukebox and was, therefore, the best value for money.

That’s how I know Mikey doesn’t play league chess. Club players loathe endings of any sort don’t they?



Ride the snake to the ancient lake baby


Endgames might not be de rigueur for those folk who play most of their chess in club matches, but tournament play seems to be a completely different kettle of fish. Having played in a few tournaments myself in the last few weeks, I’m starting to appreciate some of the differences between these two forms of the game. For a start it became clear to me pretty quickly that my knowledge and understanding of basic endgame technique was pretty poor.

Take the position at the head of today’s post. I saw it, or something very close, crop up in game in one of the tournament for lower rated players at Golders Green in January. A small crowd had gathered around the board. I wonder if those spectators were, like your humble scribe, trying to remember whether this position was won for White or not.

I knew that a centre pawn would be a win,



White to play


White securing the point by using checks to force the enemy king in front of his pawn and then bring his king one square nearer with the tempo that s/he's gained, and I also knew that a rook’s pawn would be a draw,



White to play


because here pushing the king to h1 leads to stalemate. I even remembered once seeing something like [update: see Adam FF's note in the comment box] this



White to play


which is now winning for White after all because when the queen lands on f2 Black will be able to move the second pawn allowing a mate on f1 (a bit tough to lose because you have too many pawns, but them's the rules of chess).

Alongside these memories I had the nagging feeling that there was a certain ending in which a queen’s, king’s or knight’s pawn was won and the bishop’s and rook’s pawn were drawn. What I couldn’t remember was why this would be. It didn’t seem likely that it could be any other ending than Queen v pawn on the 7th, but why would the bishop’s pawn ending in front of me be different from this?



White to play


I couldn’t remember, and I couldn’t work it out, neither at the time nor on the tube on the way home. As soon as I got back I looked it up and discovered that I’d been right, the position with a bishop’s pawn is a theoretical draw. I also found out that not only had White had no clue how to go about winning this ending – that much had been obvious – but Black hadn’t known how to draw it either. He kept defending the pawn instead of putting his king in the corner and allowing the pawn to fall.  Continuing the way he was going could have led to a defeat if White had worked out that she needed to bring her king up.



Queen takes pawn
Stalemate!


What a trio we made: none of us doing a very good job of understanding what is, after all, a rather simple and easily learned ending. The players themselves were obviously rather inexperienced and perhaps not to be expected to have acquired this basic knowledge yet. What was my excuse though? After more than two decades of club chess shouldn’t I have learned to have played this ending by now?



The blue bus is calling us


The truth is, I did once know about this ending. I’d forgotten, though, because until now I have played most of my chess in club games and this sort of thing has simply never cropped up.  Hardly any of my games come down to endings of any sort, let alone one as far as advanced as queen v pawn on the seventh. When it comes down to it, I didn’t retain what I’d learned because I didn’t need to remember it.

Since I'm aiming to play tournaments on a regular basis this year I've decided that it's time I turned this around  I still don’t know much about endgames (yet), but at least I’ve lost my passive antipathy towards positions with only a few pieces left on the board. Chess ain’t free, after all. Why not play for as long as possible and get the most value for my money? If only I’d listened to Mikey and Jim Morrison in the first place, I wouldn’t have missed out for all these years.






Saturday, February 19, 2011

A Literary Reference : A Bad Night For Burglars


They played in the front room. The burglar drew the white pieces in the first game, opened King's Pawn, and played what turned out to be a reasonably imaginative version of the Ruy Lopez. At the sixteenth move Trebizond forced the exchange of knight for rook, and not long afterward the burglar resigned.

In the second game the burglar played the black pieces and offered the Sicilian Defense. He played a variation that Trebizond wasn't familiar with. The game stayed remarkably even until in the end game the burglar succeeded in developing a passed pawn. When it was clear he would be able to queen it, Trebizond tipped over his king, resigning.

"Nice game," the burglar offered.
Lawrence Block, A Bad Night For Burglars. From The Collected Mystery Stories, Orion, 2002, p.53-4. (Original date of UK publication 1999.)

[A Literary Reference index]

[Thanks to my brother Richard]

Friday, February 18, 2011

The Board Beside Me V

The following is a true story
Only the names have been changed
To protect the guilty


AC/DC


Our Guy v Their Guy, Aragón Team Championship February 2011

So I was playing in this match a couple of Saturdays ago. I was on board two, of four, and around the time I finished, this was happening immediately to my left, on board three. Black was to play.

Black is of course winning: White had been very lucky to survive a deeply dicky middlegame and rather than welcome the equal ending which actually arose, he'd tried to win it and only succeeded, as you may have surmised, in achieving a position in which both sides staged similar attacks on the opponent's king but Black's was a couple of tempi ahead.

A couple of tempi shortly became a couple of pawns and when the position above was reached Black, whose rook is attacked, had the opportunity to take a third with that same rook. At which point White's resignation might have been considered somewhat overdue.

I almost wrote "Black can win as he pleases". But the problem, perhaps, was that he couldn't win precisely as he pleased, since his pleasure was, apparently, to keep all four of his pawns, which goal could not be achieved by the otherwise obvious 1...Rxe3 2.Nxf7 Nxh4. So how to preserve the vital f-pawn?

Black hit upon the solution: the zwischenzug 1...Nd6 which countered White's attack on the Black rook with a similar attack on the White rook.


Ingenious! Now after the rook moves, Black can take the pawn on e3, which also means he'll be attacking the White knight. No doubt White also considered lines such as 2.Rd7 (or Rb6) Rxe3 3.Ng4 Rg3+, maintaining his attack on the knight and thus consolidating his material advantage. And of course, preserving the vital f-pawn.

No doubt.

What he paid a little less attention to was the possibility that White might move the rook to b8 with check


which he duly did. There followed a king move and the removal of Black's rook.

After which, Black resigned. He didn't look particularly distressed. He didn't actually look like he thought anything abnormal had happened. I suppose it's not compulsory.



[The Board Beside Me index]

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Saturated in imagination and introversion

Working with a wide range of materials, ranging from rare and discontinued toys to small wooden sculptures to chess pieces, [artist Kris] Kuksi spends countless hours scouring the internet and local hobby shops to unearth the injection-moulded treasures which comprise much of his stunning assemblage works.
Such as -


- that one called The Beast of Babylon. Very nice.

But . . . where are those chess pieces?

A prize for the first reader to locate one; pictures of the artist's sculptures can be found here.

(Quote from here.)

Monday, February 14, 2011

Valentine's Day




The perfect valentine's gift for a loved one? That rather lovely chess set.







Found by Martin Smith



Saturday, February 12, 2011

We are not amused VIII

Once again, after a little wait, chess of sorts, appears in a London art gallery. At Tate Modern this time, in an exhibition of multiple media art-work by Mexican Gabriel Orozco. In fact, there are three chessed-up pieces.

First along there’s a 16x16 chess board, in four colours, with sixty knights of the same stripe. No other pieces, no kings, so no mate – they are Horses Endlessly Running (1995).


You can read in the Tate bookshop that Orozco is a “consummate games player”. Chess must be one of them because the knights are placed with a knowing eye. All but eight (I’ve counted them) are a knight’s move from a partner, and the others are just a hop away from finding one. For now the "horses" seem immobile and zugzwanged, but at any moment some deus ex machina might send all sixty spinning into an infinite repetition of moves.

The piece negates our usual motivation: we play to win (mostly). Same thing in another room where you can see Orozco playing with another game: bar billiards without pockets, the red hanging on by a thread, and no pots possible.

Carambole with Pendulum (1996)
© The artist.

Go on. Grab a cue, make up some rules, and go endlessly funning, even if Orozco paradoxically says (in a video accompanying the exhibition) that his art work "is not about entertaining or mesmerising”. Instead, he says it “needs concentration” on “what’s behind the gesture.”

What’s that again? “Not about entertaining.” You must be joking, hombre. We are not amused.

Then there’s another chess-vibed piece, and this time you will be looking for "what's behind the gesture" as Orozco prescribes. It is Black Kites (1997).


Not much of a laugh in this one, to be sure, just an eerie fascination, with our favourite check motif drawn taut over the grimacing death head. Exculpatory skulls seem to be a Mexican thing, as on the Day of the Dead when they sculpt them in sugar to honour the ancestors. Our man has taken a real skull and decorated it with graphite: a carbon based life-form reincarnated as carbon covered death-form.

It puts Damien Hirst’s For the Love of God (2007) well in the shade. He also encrusted a skull with the black stuff, but in the form of ostentatious glitzed-up diamond, in thrall as he is to the bloated money-bags of the international art market. The coincidence with, and contrast to, Orozco, is more than an accident.

For the Love of God Mammon.

Orozco’s repertoire ranges from chance - re-formed games, found objects reconfigured, the contingent caught on camera - to determinism, with system-pieces such as Samurai Tree Invariant Paintings 2006-7, where the knight’s move again makes a serial appearance.

There are several of these "invariants" in the show, and once again the bookshelves provide an insight. These “diagrams”, as Orozco calls them, are rule-generated: so the colours, shapes and orientations are determined by six instructions (including, explicitly, a knight hop) creating 672 end-states – all reproduced in one handy volume in the shop, though the three or four in the exhibition are enough to make the point.

Samurai Tree; Invariant Blue (2005)

The Samurai series show a lot of Geometry, to use Levitt and Friedgood’s categories, but precious little Flow. If you’ve got the time, and instead of Geometry you want some of the other, pop in to Bridget Riley’s endlessly stunning little exhibition at the National Gallery.

Red With Red 1 (2007)
Bridget Riley.


Horses for courses endlessly punning: it's the place to go for a lovely Flow job.

Acknowledgements
Black Kites images come from here.
For the Love of God
from
here.
Invariant Blue from here.
Thanks to Morgan for the reminder about the Tate expo.

Chess in Art Index

Friday, February 11, 2011

De Mooi the merrier

I still remember the first time I went to London, as a lad, to see a band: it was at the old Hammersmith Odeon. I can still remember the seat number on the ticket and everything: I can also, regrettably, recall that the band was Status Quo, my musical tastes having changed a little in the subsequent thirty years. (Perhaps more than the band themselves have changed. I was amused to note that their Wikipedia page uses the term "currently" in relation to the year 2008, which will surprise many of their fans....who may think we are still in 1975. Not that this site has any problem with nostalgia items.) They were probably on one of their innumerable farewell tours, even then, when I saw them back in February 1981.

For some reason this came to mind when it came to my attention that another old rocker will be starting a UK tour next week - beginning, coincidentally, thirty years to the day since I saw the Quo. Compère, acting in (as I understand it) a personal capacity, is the estimable CJ de Mooi, ECF President and star of Eggheads. It looks like both Nosher and CJ are branching out into exciting new directions, and we wish them well.

I notice that CJ is, in fact, revamping his website, and the new format, while attractive, doesn't, yet, have quite the detail of the old one, parts of which you can see below. (Click to enlarge.)


This is unfortunate, though no doubt it will be rectified soon, as it previously enabled us to read details of CJ's pre-Eggheads career, when he was a young actor with a role in Threads


and then, after a number of years in modelling:
"the acclaimed Zimbabwe miniseries Heat Of The Sun and the popular science fiction series Bugs".
It's a shame to lose this information, albeit only temporarily, since other sources seem to lack it: notably a resource I previously considered authoritative, the Internet Movie Database. Oddly, that site's records appear to be incomplete, since looking all the full cast and crew lists of the three shows listed - Threads, Bugs and Heat Of The Sun - I cannot find CJ listed.

Now obviously I'm aware that CJ de Mooi is not his birth name, and was apparently coined, by himself, "when he first reached adulthood":
he decided he wanted to make a name for himself, and he started by doing just that – literally. He made up the name Connagh-Joseph de Mooi, the last bit being Dutch for "the pretty one".
although he was still competing in quizzes as Joseph Connagh as late as 2000, after Heat of the Sun and Bugs (both unmentioned here). Still, no Joseph Connagh is mentioned in the cast lists either.

Never mind, one can use as many names as one likes - the present writer certainly has - and presumably, if we search for people who were involved in both Bugs and Heat Of The Sun, we will find CJ somewhere. Though I do not think that he is Hugh Bonneville, nor Flora Montgomery, and the other five people listed are not actors.

It's a mystery. But IMDB is not perfect: and if and when it is updated, then CJ's career as a television and even a film actor (as his Twitter bio used to say)


will, at last, be properly acknowledged.

[Thanks to Tom, Jonathan and Sean for various help with this]
[Nosher index]
[CJ index]

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Keene's Move









Click for a closer look

Keene's Gambit
Ray Keene Index

Wednesday, February 09, 2011

Almost Here . . .

. . . the chess movie we've all been waiting for. Mate:
Two former world chess champions battle wits to determine the greatest champion in history. After one is mysteriously killed, the other is unsuspectingly catapulted into a deadly conspiracy that he must win on and off the board if he is to escape the same fate.

Monday, February 07, 2011

Chess Pub: A Review (Part II)

After a week away to ponder the state of chess journalism, today sees the completion of my review of Chess Pub, the chess theory website.   Consider TIFE XIV and Part I the preamble and general overview respectively and this post a more detailed look at the Chess Pub world.  Indulge me for a moment, though.  I want to begin with a conversation that I witnessed several years ago:-

5 year old boy: Mum, I need some crisps.

Mother: You don’t need some crisps, you want some crisps.

The mum – a friend of mine – then turned to me and explained to me that she was trying to teach her son the difference between needing something and wanting it. “Good luck with that”, I thought but didn’t say, “I’ve got thirty years on the nipper and I still struggle to distinguish one from the other.”

Not much has changed since then. As I write these very words, for example, I’m sitting in Earl Grey and Rose, just over the road from Streatham Hill station, enjoying a cup of tea and eyeing-up the cakes they have on the counter. There’s a layer cake (heavy on the icing), a lemon drizzle and at least three different kinds of cupcake up there. All of them look extremely tasty; all of them I want; none of them can I, in any way, claim will do me much good.

As it happens this is also pretty much how I see Chess Pub - a tasty cake that I want, but don't need.  In what follows I'll try to justify that position, for the most part referring to the website's French Defence section for the simple reason that that's the one that I've looked at most closely.  Initially I'll look at the Chess Pub archive and updates then move on to consider the question of whether internet based products like this one mean the end of books and DVDs.  Hopefully, what I have to say will be relevant to people who are considering subscribing to other areas and not just those who like to play ... e6 in response to 1 e4.


THE ARCHIVE

As I mentioned two weeks ago, Chess Pub first opened its doors more than a decade ago its archive of annotated games has grown into something quite substantial. At the time of writing some 1,338 annotated games are available in The French section alone.

1,000+ games is all very well, but it won’t do you much good if they’re all in lines that don’t interest you. After checking out the French Exchange, the first thing I did was have a look at what material they had on some of the variations that have caught my eye of late.

First I took a look at a sharp line recommended for Black by Simon Williams in the DVD on the French that he released last year (reviewed here).



Winawer Poisoned Pawn: 12 ...d4!?


… Bd7 is probably the traditional mainline, but 12 … d4 seemed the perfect place to begin. It’s one of those lines that can be completely destroyed (or rehabilitated) by a single new move, and since Kamsky played it in a couple of super-GM tournaments at the beginning of last year, it’s become highly fashionable.

You’d have to wonder about the value of a website dedicated to opening theory if it didn’t have much material devoted to this line. In the Chess Pub archive, though, I found 62 games that followed the main lines and no fewer than 14 games in this newer variation, many of which were played recently (6 from 2010 and 5 from 2009).

Next I checked out a basic variation in the Advance - 1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 e5 c5, 4 c3 Nc6, 5 Nf3 Qb6, 6 a3 Nh6, 7 b4 cxd4, 8 cxd4 Nf5, 9 Bb2 Bd7 - as seen in Duffer’s Delight III, and found 11 games.

After that, I wondered what I'd find if I decided that as well as the Winawer I wanted to be able to play some safer lines with 3 … Nf6, basing my repertoire, say, on Watson’s recommendations in Play the French 3 (Everyman, 2003). Would Chess Pub help with that?

1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 Nc3 Nf6, 4 e5 Nfd7, 5 f4 c5, 6 Nf3 Nc6, 7 Be3 cxd4, 8 Nxd4 Bc5, 9 Qd2 O-O, 10 O-O-O a6 – 28 games (3 from 2010, 3 from 2009 and 13 in total played after PtF was published).

1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 Nc3 Nf6, 4 Bg5 dxe4, 5 Nxe4 Be7, 6 Bxf6 Bxf6 – 22 games (0 from 2010, 2 from 2009 and a dozen played post PtF).

Finally, I checked out Moskalenko’s “Black Queen Blues”, 1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 Nc3 Bb4, 4 e5 c5, 5 a3 Bxc3+, 6 bxc3 Qa5 !?, as used by Shulman to beat Nakamura at the American Championships last May - 18 games (3 2010, 4 2009)

and the Fort Knox Defence, 1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 Nc3/Nd2 dxe4 4 Nxe4 Bd7 – 43 games (no fewer than 10 played by Neil McDonald but none since 2008).

The coverage seems to be pretty broad, then, with the numbers I found indicating a policy of putting the most focus on the most fashionable variations at any given time. Perhaps for that reason there are some lines that didn’t seem to get much attention at all.  For example, there are just four games that feature 1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 Nd2 c5, 4 exd5 exd5, 5 Ngf3 Nc6, the old-fashioned way for Black to answer the Tarrasch, and a mere three that begin 1 e4 e6, 2 d3 d5, 3 Nd2.

In my experience The King’s Indian Attack is played rather frequently at club level, but, given that its popularity is out of all proportion to its theoretical status, it’s probably no surprise that it doesn’t get much attention on Chess Pub. It’s a shame that there aren’t more of those IQP Tarrasch positions, though. To be fair, it’s hardly all the rage either at higher-levels and many amateur chessers don’t like it because it’s perceived to be a bit dull, so I can see why there aren’t many to be found.



Dull? Dunno. Is it isolated?


These reservations aside, it seems to me that the coverage for most branches of the French Defence is very good. Indeed, I would say that anybody who wants to punt the sharper lines of the sort recommended by Williams on The Killer French should probably consider a Chess Pub subscription to be an essential purchase.

Consider the diagram above that shows the position as Black plays 12 … d4. You get to this by

1 e4 e6, 2 d4 d5, 3 Nc3 Bb4, 4 e5 c5, 5 a3 Bxc3+, 6 bxc3 Ne7, 7 Qg4 Qc7, 8 Qxg7 Rg8, 9 Qxh7 cxd4, 10 Ne2 Nc6, 11 f4 dxc3, 12 Qd3

Williams, for example, looks at 12 h4 as an alternative for White but not 12 Nxc3. It looks funny (“What's this? Hasn't this been refuted long ago?” – John Watson on Chess Pub) but in fact it doesn’t just drop a piece to … Nxe5 and Chess Pub has three games in which it was tried in 2010 including one by Shirov and one by Karjakin. This last one is particularly interesting because it was played against Sutovsky who (a) was rated 2660 at the time, and (b) has worked with Kamsky in the past and may well have helped him prepare the line for his World Championship eliminator match against Topalov. If Karjakin was prepared to employ 12 Nxc3 in such an encounter it’s clearly an idea worthy of attention.

There is also the obvious advantage that Chess Pub includes games played after Williams’ DVD was released. One line given on the Killer French ends in this position,



Winawer Poisoned Pawn Theory
White to play


with Black said to have “a very good game.” In the most recent update Watson includes the following game in which a near 2600 GM goes down against a player 200 points below him on the rating list.




Not that I think Chess Pub makes Williams’ DVD redundant. I shall have more to say about the use of the archive as a standalone resource a little later. In the meantime suffice to say that, all things considered, I feel that for the French section at least, the archive alone is worth the price (£12) of a subscription.


THE UPDATES

The updates for each section are simply more of the same. Not that is in any way a bad thing. Typically eight to ten games will be analysed, some with other complete games included in the notes. From time to time older encounters will be looked at – e.g. some of Simon Williams’ recent update on the Classical Dutch for Chess Pub’s ‘Daring Defences’ section – but for the most part the selections are topical. Watson’s January update for the French includes Caruana-Short played at Reggio Emilia just before New Year’s Eve and even Smeets-Ponomariov, who’d met at Wijk aan Zee literally days before the update appeared, makes it in.

Nosher’s game, by the way, appeared shortly after I’d lamented the lack of the IQP Tarrasch games in the Chess Pub Forum. That was, I’m sure, a coincidence, but interaction with subscribers is encouraged, and authors often take a look at certain positions at the direct request of subscribers.

All in all, given that a year’s subscription will bring you 12 x eight (or more) annotated games, i.e. 96 in total, the cost seems pretty reasonable when compared to the price of a chess book or a DVD. All the more so when you consider that you get access to that section’s archive too.


THE END OF BOOKS AND DVDS?

If Chess Pub is so great, you might be wondering, does it mean I don’t have to buy books and/or DVDs anymore? The answer to that, I think, is ‘no’. Learning an opening from scratch using this website alone could be quite tricky for two reasons.

Firstly, there’s just so much material available it’s not necessarily going to be easy to navigate your way through it unless you already have some idea of what you’re looking for it. Also, when you search for games that begin from a particular position you can be sure that the computer will spit plenty out, but they won’t necessarily have appeared in the updates in the order that they were played. While this isn’t necessarily disastrous, it takes some work to check that the comments to any given game haven’t been superseded by something that came along later.

Secondly, some basic knowledge is taken for granted by the section authors. This position,



Slav Theory
Black to play


comes from one of the Slav main lines. In all the games in the Chess Pub database, Black continues with … 0-0. If you are new to this line, though, you're first thought might be to wonder why you can’t grab a pawn by taking on c3 and then on e4. The answer is that ever since Kasparov-Bareev, Tilburg 1991 it’s been thought keeping Black’s king in the centre with Ba3 gives White more than enough compensation.

Even if it rarely appears in GM encounters these days, understanding – or at least knowing of – this pawn sac is really rather necessary to justify both sides’ play in this line, but Chess Pub won’t tell you about it. Neither, incidentally, does it mention the fact that, club players often play … 0-0 before … Nbd7 to avoid those forced drawing lines that result from Qb3 and Qxb7 a few moves before the diagram position.

For these reasons, then, I think Chess Pub will work best as a supplement to existing sources rather than a complete replacement for them.


PROBLEMS?

Is there a downside to Chess Pub? I have a few minor quibbles, but that is all.

Firstly, although you can view/play through the games and analysis online, you lose access to this facility when your subscription expires. You’ll probably get most out of Chess Pub if you have a database to store and sort the games, but, that said, I know my fellow blogger EJH manages to be a happy subscriber without (yet) handing over any Euros to Fred Friedel.

Secondly, in the past there has been the occasional issue of updates for some sections being delivered several months late. Clearly for a website that is supposed to be a topical resource, this would a significant problem. Happily, at the moment all sections seem to be on schedule with many updates being delivered in the early days of the month.

Finally, when exploring the archive for games played in the Dutch Defence, I noticed quite a few that were not actually annotated. These seem to stem from the time when Jon Tisdall was in charge of that section. There’s literally not a single note or variation given, just a few lines of introduction at the beginning.

I don’t know how many of the 16,000 games in the database as a whole are like this. It’s probably not that many; the real issue is that the quality your subscription will vary according who the author of the section is.

Subscribers interested in the French Defence have been lucky to have Neil McDonald and now John Watson as their guides. Similarly, if, say, I was interested in the Dragon, I’d want Chris Ward and Corporal Jones to be around to explain it to me. For the other sections, though, I don’t know enough about the individual authors to be able to make a judgement as to how good their work for Chess Pub is likely to be.



photograph from RAW Baking


All in all, I find Chess Pub to be a very good, value-for-money resource for anybody interested in keeping up with the developments in opening theory in their favourite lines. The only thing you can say against it is that you almost certainly don’t really need it.

Everybody knows that, save for those higher up the ladder, improvements in results are much more likely to be achieved by building up our middlegame and endgame skills: enhancing our tactical ability, gaining an understanding of a broader range of positional themes, learning how to mate with bishop and knight against king and so forth. These are the things that will really help.

Books on the opening might be the most popular amongst us amateurs, but they don’t necessarily do us much good do they? In my own games I tend to play folk up in the 150 to 170 ECF Grade range (around 1850 to 2000 elo range) and sometimes up to around 180/190 (2100+). Only rarely do I face what the books say are the most testing lines.

Why bother learning the theory if you never get a chance to play it? Well, it’s not for everybody, but a lot of people – myself included – find keeping abreast of theoretical developments interesting in and of itself. There’s also the obvious point that playing through master games in your favourite lines is likely to help your understanding of kind of structures and themes that arise in those openings.

Ultimately, while we might not need all that stuff on the opening that we buy, if we’re going to shell out money anyway we might as well get something good. Chess Pub is that alright. It’s not necessary, but I do want it. In fact, I’ve just gone ahead and bought myself a one-year subscription to the French section and now, review written, I think I’ll have that cake too. Lemon Drizzle will do nicely.